Walter Finch
SPAIN’S Supreme Court has ruled that the time taken for a morning coffee break and period employees take to settle into the working day should count as part of their hours worked.
The decision allows workers a courtesy margin of up to 15 minutes at the start of the day – if this has been agreed between the company and workers beforehand.
This decision stems from a dispute involving the employees of Caixabank and its top brass over the latter’s assertion that hours worked must be a ‘faithful reflection of reality.’
The ruling specifically addresses a 1991 agreement between unions and the bank, which stipulated that clock-ins within 15 minutes before or after the scheduled start time are counted as effective work time.
However, in 2019 Caixabank released a new ‘Time Registration Guide’ which argued the opposite, provoking the trade unions to go up in arms.
The new guide claimed ‘the breakfast break is not counted as effective time, unless it has been dedicated to professional or commercial tasks.’
It also introduced a new clocking-in system, meaning that if an employee arrived five minutes late, they would be obliged to leave five minutes later.
The workers’ unions objected to both claims on the grounds that they violated the 1991 agreement of labour rights
The Supreme Court came down in favour of the unions, ruling against the new strict clocking-in system.
“If a marking is made within the fifteen minutes after the start time, it is considered to have occurred at the beginning of the start time and, therefore, it is effective work time,” it said in its ruling.
“The fact that the breakfast break is not recorded as an absence or an incident leads to the understanding, without any interpretive effort, that this break is considered effective work.”
READ MORE:
- Is charging a ‘premium’ for tables in the sun – or shade – legal in Spain? All you need…
- New high-speed rail routes in Spain: British expat hotspots on the Costa Blanca will be directly connected to these…
